CPAC

Supreme Court Hearings

Loading video...

Supreme Court Hearings - Gordon Garland v. Enbridge Gas Distribution Inc. (Part 3 of 3) / Morris Fish


The court hears arguments in case #29052, Gordon Garland v. Enbridge Gas Distribution Inc., previously known as “The Consumers’ Gas Company Limited,” on October 9, 2003.

The Consumers’ Gas Company Limited, now known as Enbridge Gas Distribution Inc., charged Gordon Garland late-payment penalties between 1983 and 1995. Mr. Garland launched a class-action lawsuit against the gas company, claiming that those penalties amounted to charging a criminal rate of interest. The case was eventually appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada, which ruled in 1998 that the late-payment penalties violated section 347 of the Criminal Code. Enbridge subsequently argued that it was not obligated to refund the penalties. The Ontario Court of Appeal agreed, a decision Mr. Garland is appealing to the Supreme Court.

Lawyer Alan Mark presents arguments on behalf of Toronto Hydro-Electric Systems Limited, an intervener in the case. Lawyer Patricia Jackson presents arguments on behalf of Union Gas Limited, an intervener in the case. Lawyer Mark Orkin presents arguments on behalf of the Law Foundation of Ontario, an intervener in the case. Lawyer Barbara Grossman presents arguments on behalf of Gordon Garland.

Also on the program, a welcoming ceremony is held at the Supreme Court of Canada in honour of Justice Morris J. Fish on October 15, 2003. Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin makes opening remarks and describes Justice Fish’s work and contributions. Federal Justice Minister Martin Cauchon is among the attendees.


more less

Related Videos

Beyond Politics

Justice Beverley McLachli...

Journalist Catherine Clark speaks with Supreme Court Judge Beverley McLachlin

Beyond Politics

Justice Richard Wagner

Journalist Catherine Clark speaks with Supreme Court Judge Richard Wagner

Beyond Politics

Justice Rosalie Abella

Journalist Catherine Clark speaks with Supreme Court Judge Rosalie Abella

Beyond Politics

Justice Clément Gascon

Catherine Clark spoke to Justice Clément Gascon in Ottawa.