CPAC is proudly owned by these leading companies
  • Rogers Logo
  • Shaw
  • Videotron Logo
  • Cogeco Logo
  • Eastlink Logo
  • Access Logo

Whipped: The Secret World of Party Discipline

   
       Loading CPAC video...    
         
   
   

| video language:    

   
   
CPAC Special

Winston Churchill once said " Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time". Governments, in democracies such as Canada, know that their hold on power is only as strong as their hold on the sitting members of their caucus. It is not unusual for MPs to find themselves in a position where they must decide between the wishes of their constituents and those of their party and it falls upon the party's whip to ensure that the MPs' choice is a simple one. For example this past spring, in Ottawa, two MPs, Brent Rathgeber and Mark Warawa gained prominence when they took positions that were at odds to those of their party's. While their deliberations were made public, more often than not, these discussions are often held behind closed doors and remain there, ensuring that the party's image remains untarnished.

In Sean Holman's documentary Whipped, the Mount Royal University journalism professor takes an in-depth look at how party discipline is enforced on the benches of the legislature in Victoria, B.C. Holman talks to former and current MLA's and cabinet ministers about how they coped or were forced to cope to the demands of their party's whip.

Comments

Submitted by Mike Summers (not verified) on
This would be the reason the NDP didn't want me as a candidate. I WON'T BE WHIPPED I WILL WORK FOR MY CONSTITUENTS MY PROVINCE and MY COUNTRY. IN THAT ORDER. The Nearly Democratic Party (not the members) ain't.

Submitted by Jeanette Ashe (not verified) on
Hi there - thank you for posting 'Whipped' Cheers, Jeanette

Submitted by Norma (not verified) on
We have corporate control - not government by the people. This has to change.

Submitted by Jesse (not verified) on
I wonder how this situation would change, if at all, if proportional representation were adopted.

Submitted by kate dyson (not verified) on
PR would change things to the extent that there would rarely be a majority and so all representatives would have to carry on a public debate...representing party policy and therefore constituent preference...and negotiate some kind of compromise to pass legislation...for the good of the public rather than the benefit of corporate and political interests...

Submitted by Paul Nollen (not verified) on
we have, here in Belgium, proportional representation and it changes nothing. In my view only direct democracy can. Paul

Submitted by Donna Chevrier (not verified) on
Thank you for this excellent in depth commentary. It is very clear that our governments are not working for Canadian citizens and having to toe the party line sounds pretty much the way that bullies get their way in the school yard. I'm not sure this was ever brought into the discussion as one more reason to move to proportional representation but having heard this, it would be one of the top reasons for making election reform an absolute must. Imagine a system where every vote counted, where we had a more diverse group of people representing us, where one party couldn't control everything and one leader had to listen to opinions and where honest debate would be the norm. Election reform seems to be our best hope for the future where constituents are taken into consideration and the dictatorship is ended. Let's make it happen.

Add new comment

Ask Martin Stringer promotional image
The CPAC Digital Archive

Daily Programming Highlights


 

Latest Comments

Paul Nollen:
we have, here in Belgium, proportional representation and it changes nothing. In my view only direct democracy can. Paul
kate dyson:
PR would change things to the extent that there would rarely be a majority and so all representatives would have to carry on a public debate
Donna Chevrier:
Thank you for this excellent in depth commentary.
Jesse:
I wonder how this situation would change, if at all, if proportional representation were adopted.